It is rather funny that I should be writing about Socialism.
I have written earlier on about the importance of Capitalism and the necessary free movement of capital and labour to the best possible location so as to derive maximum economic return. In fact, I think there should be totally free movement of qualified capital and labour across the world.
Well, I have not abandoned those principles, I still believe that free Capitalism is the best form of economic model out there and we have seen how even a socialistic country like India could transform by adopting capitalism. There is no doubt in my mind that entrepreneurs and established industrialists would not be driven by patriotism only, they would rather be driven by demand and economic returns on invested capital and labour.
However, this might be a good occasion to relook at some fundamental principles from a government and governance perspective. It is critical to ensure that no person is left to die on the streets for want of medical care or food. The State (government) is responsible for ensuring that poverty and restricted access to government or private resources should not stand in the way of providing essential items or care to people below the poverty line.
I am not talking about subsidies here. The subsidies that the Indian government provides to various sectors of the economy are untenable even in the medium term, and I believe these will disappear soon. Imagine if those subsidies are used to fund the healthcare and education needs of the poor people at the bottom of the society. Given that the bottom part of the Indian society is probably more than 200 million people, a significant 18 to 20% of the overall population, there is an urgent need for the government to ensure their well being.
I am writing this piece, as I was impacted by published stories by news media on the plight of very poor “street” people who were turned away from government hospitals in Kolkata. This really hurts any decent person’s sentiments and one tends to think “what is this government doing – do they even care ?”. It was pathetic to see the husband of the lady who died for want of medical care, carrying two just-born kids who would now be left without their mother in this cruel world of insensitive Indians (and Indian government).
Please see the news item in Times of India “Two hospitals ‘refuse’ admission, woman dies after delivering twins”
Actions have to be immediately taken to ensure that such scenarios do not repeat in any part of the country. The administrator of the hospital should be summarily dismissed, sending a very strong message to the medical community that they have to live by their motto of service to mankind and Hippocratic Oath. Of all people, medical administrators and doctors in India cannot behave as though they are disconnected from the problems of the poor people on the street without any resources. In fact, they should go out of their way for ensuring delivery of immediate medical attention without any consideration.
Teaching our children about socialism and empathy is now becoming very critical in this extremely materialistic world of India. How do we ensure that our children are not insensitive to the sufferings around them ? How do we involve them in difficult community service, wherein they would come face to face with the human sufferings of the very poor people of India ? What can the government do to ensure that no one dies on our streets for lack of food or health care ?
Instead of tackling such huge problems, our government is embroiled in scandal after scandal and frittering away our scarce resources on funding Air India type of companies which should have gone away long time ago. Let us worry about the poor people of this country who are poorer than the folks in sub-Saharan Africa and ensure that the benefits of a growing economy trickle down to them as well. This might require “start-up” thinking.
Cheers,
Vijay Srinivasan
15th January 2012
Mumbai